the Concord MagazineFeb '99

A Senseless Act Begets Revenge and Propaganda

By D. Michael Ryan, company Historian with the Concord Minute Men, an 18th Century volunteer historic interpreter with the National Park Service and Associate Dean of Students at Boston College.

old north bridgeIt was a momentary, thoughtless, atrocious act committed by a young man in the aftermath of the North Bridge fight. But both the incident and its perpetrator, long shrouded in silence, would profoundly impact remaining events on 19 April 1775.

As the British Regulars fled the bridge, Col. Barrett's men pursued a short distance. According to Rev. Emerson's account, a wounded British soldier, left behind, attempted to rise and was assaulted by a young fellow going to join his American countrymen. The culprit "not under the feelings of humanity, barbarously broke his (soldier's) skull" with a small hatchet. Acton's Thomas Thorp would note that he was horrified by the sight.

Ens. Jeremy Lister, among the British troops returning from Barrett's farm, came upon his comrade and later wrote, "4 men...killd who afterwards scalp'd their eyes goug'd their noses and ears cut of, such barbarity execut'd upon the Corps could scarcely be paralelled by the most uncivilised savages". Five other soldiers would declare seeing the wounded man with the skin over his eyes cut and also the top part of his ears cut off. As word spread among the British troops in Concord that Americans were scalping and mauling the dead and wounded, attitudes turned from contempt to fear and hate.



LTC Smith, commanding the Concord expedition, reported to Lord Percy and General Gage that "after the bridge was quitted, they scalped and otherwise ill-treated one or two of the men who were either killed or severely wounded". Gage would write in his summaries, "... one scalped, his head much mangled and his ears cut off, though not quite dead...a sight which struck the soldiers with horror". Rumors even circulated that eyes had been forced from the dying soldier's sockets. What actually occurred may only be known to the victim, the young culprit and possibly Rev. Emerson, who witnessed the event from beside his home, the Old Manse. The minister acknowledged a fateful ax blow but insisted that the soldier was neither scalped nor his ears cut off but that he did languish for hours before expiring.

Various explanations for the cause of this deed were advanced. The culprit was "half-witted"; excused only by excitement and inexperience; startled by the soldier and acted out of fear; acting to end the soldier's suffering. Extreme claims noted that the victim was trying to drown himself in a water puddle and begged someone to kill him; had thrust at the American with his bayonet; or was an escaping prisoner. None of these theories have a basis in fact and had such mitigating circumstances existed, would certainly have been mentioned by the witness Rev. Emerson.



While the British publicized the incident, Americans chose to ignore it possibly due to embarrassment, fear of reprisals, failure to appreciate its importance or a notion that it would blot a historic cause. Provincial authorities hesitated to confirm that the act had occurred but in response to a Boston story insured that the burial detail testified that "neither of those persons (2 dead soldiers buried at the bridge) were scalped nor their ears cut off". Concord historians Ripley and Shattuck ignored the incident completely while well into the 19th Century, British historians continued to write of the scalping and ear cutting episode.

A long guarded secret was the name of the young culprit who tradition acknowledges as Ammi White. Emerson knew it and might have told Rev. William Gordon during interviews the latter conducted a few days after the battle. Yet as late as 1932, Allen French interviewed an elderly women who was reluctant to mention the ax wielder's name. Stories abounded that the person was a wood-chopping chore boy of the Emerson's or their African servant, Frank. The former did not exist and the latter was accounted for by the family members.



Most probably Ammi White was the young man. Born around 1754, he was a young private in Capt. Brown's company. Though troubled and haunted throughout his life by the incident, in 1807 he confided to Charles Handley that at the time he thought he was doing right. White survived the war, married Mary Minot in 1788 and lived in one end of her family's Concord home (Colonial Inn). He eventually moved to Westmoreland, NH where he died in 1820 at age 66. Nathaniel Hawthorne, having heard the ax story from James Russell Lowell, wrote of it in "Mosses from an Old Manse", brooding over White's life and how his soul was tortured by the blood stain.

The British troops returning to Boston would remember the "scalping" with fear, anger and a sense of revenge. This coupled with civilian hostility in Boston and cowardly tactics of the colonials along the retreat route would lead to bloody reprisals and British atrocities (house burnings, killing of unarmed men, bayoneting of wounded and dead colonials, etc.) especially in the village of Menotomy. Lord Percy's relief column had been informed of the "scalping" and Gen. Gage would later use it to off-set atrocity charges against his troops.

Thus did an inauspicious incident, on 19 April 1775 near North Bridge by a little known private have a major impact on the culprit's life, later military actions and propaganda efforts by the British.


Go to: Concord Homepage     Subscribe     Table of Contents     Previous page     Next page   Back issues    Contact us


This page sponsored by:

do you like books?

See your message here! More Info



Go to: Concord Homepage     Subscribe    Table of Contents Previous page     Next page    Back issues    Contact us


...word spread that Americans were scalping and mauling the dead and wounded...


Sources

The Day of Concord and Lexington by Allen French, 1925

Paul Revere's Ride by David Hackett Fischer, 1994

We Were There by Vincent J. R. Kehoe, 1974

Gordon's American War by Rev. William Gordon, 1790

The Nineteenth of April 1775 by Harold Murdock, 1925



Background from Set City.
North Bridge photo courtesy of Art Today


This website is a gift to the Concord community from Hometown Websmith, a full-service Internet marketing company. 978 369-0113. PO Box 285 - Concord, MA 01742 webmaster@concordma.com